Weight Watchers, Jenny Craig most reliable for weight loss, study says

Notifications

Weight Watchers vs. Nutrisystem vs. Jenny Craig
The researchers say "Nutrisystem shows promise, but the lack of long-term [randomized clinical trials] precludes definitive conclusions. My mother took place in both these programs over the course of her life. The Dangers of Weight Watchers. South Beach Diet Vs. The Jenny Craig program resulted in more weight loss than Weight Watchers. They rely on low-cal meal-replacement products like bars or shakes to promote faster short-term weight loss. Probably less, however, since you will be making better choices.

What to Read Next

These Beat Other Commercial Diet Plans: Study

Altogether, the researchers combed through more than 3, studies and considered different weight-loss programs. But only 11 of the programs had been tested in rigorous clinical trials that lasted at least 12 weeks. Three of the programs relied on diets that delivered a mere to 1, calories per day. Among these, the Health Management Resources plan recorded the most weight loss — The other two programs produced short-term results that weren't sustained. Dieters using Medifast lost 5.

Another five weight-loss programs were described as "self-directed," including three Internet-based plans. Among them, only the Biggest Loser Club was found to have any success — after three months, users lost 2. Another trial found that people who tried Lose It! A third trial tracked users of eDiets for a year and found they fared no better than people who got counseling. The researchers also found eight clinical trials involving Atkins.

In those studies, Atkins followers lost 0. Another trial compared a group of Atkins dieters with a control group that got only education. That's because the experience of real-world dieters may differ from that of clinical trial participants, they said. But the researchers who conducted the analysis hope their findings will also be useful to doctors.

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act advises physicians to screen for obesity and make sure patients in need get appropriate counseling and treatment. In addition, the American Heart Assn.

Indeed, some states are already experimenting with sending their Medicaid patients to Weight Watchers, the only program that was endorsed in the review.

However, this assumption "would need to be confirmed in future studies," she added. There are also weekly meetings and weigh-ins to attend. Jenny Craig users mostly just eat the food that is delivered to them, but they will still need to meet with their counselors, and once they leave the plan, learn more about counting calories to maintain their weight loss. News and Health Report. Jenny Craig requires an initial registration fee, followed by weekly payments for prepackaged food.

Weight Watchers gives you the option of paying for unlimited monthly meetings or paying per meeting for only the meetings you attend. You also have the option you purchase access to the online program exclusively. Video of the Day. The Diet Center Diet Plan. Free Weight Watchers Meal Plan. South Beach Diet Vs. The Dangers of Weight Watchers. Price of Nutrisystem Food Vs. The "Walking for Weight Loss" Program. The Success Rate of Weight Watchers. Weight Watcher Points for Olive Garden.

Healthy Snacks for Weight Watchers.

Which Program is Best?